What do hosts they do? Why do we need them? And what makes a good host?
At first it seems that the host is useless. The host doesn't perform, doesn't judge, doesn't do anything but hold a mic and
read off a teleprompter. But the host plays a very important role. The host is nice to the contestants whether they suck or not. Basically he is the opposite of a judge (except Paula). He doesn't judge, he is a go between. Between the contestants and the judges. Between the contestants and the audience. Basically these shows need a true host, not just a nameless faceless voice, that is to say, an announcer. Some of these shows have an announcer too, but usually their role is limited to announcing the hosts arrival on the stage and making the host feel better by being even less useful (and less paid).
Hosts run the gamut from unmemorable to annoying to a complete tool to just another pretty face. What makes a good host, and what makes a bad host? Let's run down our sample shows to see what qualities their hosts do or do not have and see what we can learn.
American Inventor
Nick Smith is wholly unmemorable. I have seen many episodes of this show, and yet I can't remember Nick Smith at all. I mean, literally, I don't have any recollection of seeing him. If there weren't a
picture of him on the website, I wouldn't even believe this show had a host. I would have thought he was an announcer. Maybe they figured since they already have a hot babe on the judging panel who became a millionaire by making naughty undergarments, that they didn't need any more sex appeal, so they just got a boring host.
Next Best ThingThe lovely Michele Merkin. Her presentation style has been criticized as being a little flat and unengaging, but she is a pretty face and the contestants seem to like her. She even seems to like the contestants. She seems to have a thing for Elvis impersonators. And she does have some hosting experience... and a
funny last name.
Previous gigs / Hosting Experience: Foody Call, Extreme Dodgeball
America's Next Top ModelTyra Banks breaks etiquette here by being both host and judge. This often puts her in a Janus like position, having to be alternately supportive and critical of the contestants. In truth, this may be the best example of why a show needs an entity that is separate and distinct from the judges.
Previous gigs: model, talk-show host
Hosting Experience: The Tyra Banks Show
American IdolRyan Seacrest seriously
looks stoned all the time on this show. I didn't notice this till I started watching the s

how in hi-def, so you fellow HD set owners out there might be able to back me up on this, but damn dude, with all the money they must be paying him, he couldn't wait to puff until
after the show? Maybe he's one of those types who likes to get stoned and do stuff. You know, like "Hey, I have to do a live TV show in like 15 minutes... in fact, the highest rated TV show in America... let's get stoned! Huh, huh. Yeah." Or maybe he really really hates doing Idol, the judges seem like they can't stand being there. They all look like they're about to kill each other, but just can't say no to the money. Or maybe he just always looks like that, but whatever it is, in my opinion, while some people are phoning it in, Ryan is stoning it in.
Former gigs: American radio, television personality, and anchorman
Hosting experience: radio host for Atlanta's WSTR, host of ESPN's "Radical Outdoor Challenge", during his early twenties, Seacrest hosted a few short-lived game shows, and he hosted the fictional gameshow "Lover's Lane" in an episode of "Beverly Hills 90210", host of Gladiators 2000, and host of
The New Edge, a weekend morning show created by CNET showcasing new technology (hm, looks like this guy really worked his way to the top... maybe I should stop being so mean to him and thinking of him as a complete tool.......... naaaaah)
America's Got Talent
Jerry Springer. Ah, Jerry Springer. I have to admit right here that I have always sort of liked Jerry Springer. He's just doing it all for the money and who can blame him. Everyone we are talking about here is doing it all for the money. Beside it
looks like he's a foot and leg man, like myself. I used to watch his show back in college and get a real kick out of it, but I've outgrown that by now.
I think he actually does a pretty decent job on
America's Got Talent. He seems to know what being a host entails, after all he has hosted his own scripted reality show for 16 years.
Former gigs: The Jerry Springer Show
Hosting Experience: The Jerry Springer Show
So You Think You Can Dance?The lovely Cat Deeley. I feel I have already
said enough about Cat and am way too biased to give any sort of objective opinion on her hosting abilities.
Former gigs: English disc jockey, television personality, and former fashion model
Hosting experience: co-hosting the UK children's series SMTV Live
On the LotChelsea Handler was fired (after one episode!) from this gig and now has her own late night talk show

on E!
She was replaced by
Adrianna Costa, a sort of poor-man's Eva Longoria. She not so great, but neither is the show, so that's okay. You don't want your host outshining your show.
Former gigs: television personality, entertainment reporter
Hosting Experience: being an entertainment reporter is similar to being a host, especially similar to the hosting requirements of on the lot... both include: announcing directors' latest films
So it looks like maybe hosts aren't so important after all, or are they? Leave your comments.